Dodgers legend Erskine dies at 97
Dana Hunsinger Benbow
Carl Erskine, a fierce fighter for human rights and All-Star for the Brooklyn Dodgers who pitched one of the greatest World Series games in history, died early Tuesday morning after a brief illness, his family confirmed to IndyStar. He was 97.
Erskine died a baseball legend who played alongside field icons Jackie Robinson and Gil Hodges. He pitched in five World Series, striking out a then-record 14 in a game in 1953. Erskine, who played for the Dodgers from 1948 to 1959, would become beloved by the fans. They affectionately called him “Oisk” in their Brooklyn accents.
But, to those who knew him best, Erskine was so much more. He was a man who, off the field, fought for what was right in the world. Erskine was a fierce champion of human rights, racial equality and, when his late son Jimmy was born with Down syndrome, became immersed in fighting for people with special needs.
“He was the best guy I’ve ever known,” said filmmaker Ted Green, who produced a documentary on Erskine, “The Best We’ve Got: The Carl Erskine Story.”
Erskine was born at home in 1926, the son of a stay-at-home mom and a father who was a grocery store manager, and later a factory worker. He grew up in what he called a “mixed neighborhood” in Anderson, Indiana.
It was the 1930s in Anderson where, 10 years before, the Ku Klux Klan had a stronghold, as it did across the state and much of the nation. Racism was rampant as Erskine came to that court in 1937, a 10-year-old white boy with nothing to prove. Just to play.
“And with every societal force pushing Carl in another direction, here on a basketball court in a back alley, he befriends a 9-year-old Johnny,” said Green.
Johnny was “Jumpin” Johnny Wilson, as he later became known in Anderson, a high school basketball superstar who along with Erskine wowed crowds of more than 5,000 at the Wigwam gym.
Erskine and Wilson led the team to the state semifinals in 1944. Anderson lost to Kokomo after Wilson was injured in semistate.
“We just couldn’t make up that 25 or 30 points Wilson usually scored,” Erskine said. “Boy did we have teamwork going for the two of us.”
Erskine and Wilson, who was Black, became more than teammates. They became best friends. The two were joined at the hip. They walked to school together every day and hung out after. They played sports together and told each other their deepest secrets.
Erskine didn’t realize it at the time, but Wilson would shape his views on race. And later in his life, someone would notice that. Erskine was in the Brooklyn Dodgers locker room when he heard a guy come up behind him, Erskine told IndyStar in 2015.
“Hey Erskine, how come you don’t have a problem with this Black and white thing?” The voice belonged to Dodgers teammate Jackie Robinson.
“I said, ‘Well, I grew up with Johnny Wilson,’” Erskine recalled. “‘I didn’t know he was Black. He was my buddy. And so I don’t have a problem.’”
Erskine quickly made a name for himself as a baseball player in Indiana. Striking kids out. Pitching no-hitters. Being written about in newspapers. He wasn’t very big, 5-10 and 165 pounds, but he had an arm.
Radar guns weren’t around back in those days so Erskine never knew exactly how fast he was throwing in high school. Later, he would get a scouting card from the Dodgers that gave him an A+ for velocity. That A+ meant he was throwing between 92 and 93 miles per hour.
After graduating in 1945, Erskine worked out for the Dodgers at Ebbets Field. He couldn’t sign because he had to serve his time in the Navy due to World War II. When the war ended the following year, Erskine signed with the Dodgers at the age of 19.
He played a winter season in Cuba and he still remembers what he made – $325 a month.
“That helped me immensely to pitch in what was about like a Triple-A caliber league,” he said in 2015.
At a preseason game in Fort Worth, Texas, in 1948, Erskine pitched four or five innings against Robinson as he was trying to make the big leagues.
“And lo and behold when the game was over, Jackie Robinson actually came over to our dugout and he said, ‘Where’s Erskine?’” he told IndyStar in 2015. “I didn’t know Jackie and I stepped out and shook hands with him. And he said, ‘Young man, I hit against you twice today. You’re not going to be here very long.’”
Robinson was right. Just a dozen games later, Erskine was called up to the Dodgers.
Robinson, Erskine and their young Dodgers team would add to an exciting era of baseball in Brooklyn. After losing seven consecutive World Series over the years, the franchise won its first title in 1955.
The Dodgers were made up of icons from that era: Robinson, Hodges, Pee Wee Reese, Roy Campanella, Preacher Roe, Duke Snider and Carl Furillo.
“We had a team that in my 12 seasons in the big leagues won the National League championship six times,” Erskine said in 2015. Erskine became a regular in the team’s starting rotation in 1951. In addition to pitching in five World Series, he pitched two no-hitters, the first in 1952 against the Cubs. He also led the National League with 20 wins in 1953.
Erskine pitched the first nationallytelevised no-hitter in 1956 against the Giants. It was the Saturday Game of the Week at a time the nation gathered around their televisions to watch.
The Brooklyn era of the Dodgers came to an end in 1958, shocking and saddening a city, when the team announced it would be moving to Los Angeles. Erskine pitched the home opener in in L.A. Dodgers Stadium wasn’t built yet, so the team played in a football stadium and 80,000 people were in the stands.
Erskine retired from baseball in 1959 and returned to Indiana where he and his wife, Betty, would raise their three children, Danny, Gary and Susan. One year later, Jimmy was born.
Jimmy Erskine was born in 1960 with Down syndrome. It was a time when many doctors told parents that babies with Down syndrome should be sent to an institution, that they would be a societal hindrance, that they would disrupt family life.
Erskine and his wife ignored what doctors said and they took Jimmy home.
Green says the Erskines blazed a trail for other families with children who had special needs.
But Erskine didn’t just make life better for Jimmy. He took to another fight, a fight to make lives better for all people with special needs.
At the time Jimmy was born, average life expectancy for babies with Down syndrome was 10 years. Jimmy Erskine would outlive his Down syndrome prognosis by decades and, along the way, became the face of Special Olympics. He died in 2023 at the age of 63.
Whenever Erskine was asked to give a speech, he would stand at the podium and hold up his World Series ring and tell the audience how much it meant to him. But then, he would always pull from his pocket one of Jimmy’s gold medals from the Special Olympics.
“You tell me which is the greater achievement,” Erskine would say to the audience. “Which of these means more?”
“The crowd would go silent,” Green said. “Then they would clap, and then the tears would fall.”