‘Labour still don’t know what a woman is!’
Anger at plan to let GPs sign off certificate for change of gender
LABOUR’S plan to make it easier to switch gender is self-identification in all but name, critics have claimed.
Sir Keir Starmer is looking at ending the need for two doctors and an expert panel to agree to a Gender Recognition Certificate by allowing a family GP to sign it off instead.
Opponents said that shows Labour “still don’t know what a woman is” and warned the reforms go too far.
Downing Street said there was “no reason whatsoever” to relax current safeguards. The Prime Minister’s spokesman said: “The process of changing one’s legal sex is a serious and meaningful undertaking.”
Tory MP Mark Jenkinson said: “This is ridiculous – it’s self-ID by another name. Labour still don’t know what a woman is.”
Labour last year ruled out introducing self-ID, whereby a person can officially change their gender without any medical assessment.
That came after an outcry when rapist Isla Bryson, who had changed gender while awaiting trial, was at first locked up in Scotland’s only women’s prison. Opponents fear self-ID might be abused by men who want to gain access to women-only areas. But under the proposals being considered, the GRC – which enables people to change the sex on their birth certificate – could be signed off by just one family doctor. Labour was warned GPs do not have the expertise or time to make such complex decisions, which will effectively lead to them rubberstamping the patient’s claim that they are now a different gender. The Royal College of General Practitioners said GPs were already under “considerable pressure”. Its chair Professor Kamila Hawthorne told The Times she would be concerned about “shifting sole responsibility for signing gender recognition certificates to GPs”. Tory deputy chair MP Jonathan Gullis said this would become “Tavistock 2.0” – a reference to the discredited clinic where many children were put on puberty blockers.A review by Dr Hilary Cass made 32 recommendations on restructuring the medical system to address the way in which trans youths receive care.
Her report declared that an entire sector of medicine was operating on “shaky foundations”, with not enough evidence in support of prescribing hormones to under-18s to pause puberty or to transition.
Labour said proposals on reforming the GRC process were floated last year and would go out to consultation before being implemented.
Anneliese Dodds, Shadow Women and Equalities Secretary, said: “Labour is the party of equality. We believe everyone should be treated with dignity and respect.
“We want to see the process for gender recognition modernised, while protecting single-sex spaces for biological women. This means stripping out the futile and dehumanising parts of the process for obtaining a gender recognition certificate, while retaining important safeguards.”