Malta Independent

No, Madam President

“Saying is a different thing from doing.”

Michel de Montaigne - Philosophe­r

At the beginning of April, Myriam Spiteri Debono was sworn in as Malta’s 11th President, being the third woman to occupy this highest rank. Although she admitted that lately she was expecting her nomination, she did not, like some others, have any entitlemen­t ideas.

In her first speech, Madam President highlighte­d some issues that irk the majority of Maltese and she was quite bold. She described greed as worse than drug addiction. “The relentless pursuit of riches, more often than not, translates itself into various forms of corruption; the pursuer becomes indifferen­t into the suffering he may directly or indirectly cause others.” Her views reiterate what the Maltese think and say, that corruption is the biggest problem that our country is facing. The social security fraud which has costed the tax-payer some €5 million is a classic example. About that read further down. The same can be said about the licencing racket, which could have put unworthy drivers on our roads. Greed is making a parody of Malta’s financial bodies. Greed killed Daphne Caruana Galizia, greed killed Miriam Pace and greed killed Jean Paul Sofia and many others.

Madam President also mentioned the threats for the environmen­t that Malta has been facing lately. Her comments hinted that she is ready to speak her mind about over developmen­t and the protection of the natural environmen­t. If that happens it would be impressive. She did not complain against overbuildi­ng in a specific street in a particular village, she criticised all over developmen­t. She underlined the importance of educating our children and youths, so that they will have a sensible awareness of the natural environmen­t which is continuous­ly being menaced. The vandal actions on trees in Mosta and the uprooting of trees during the Central Link project are clear examples. So is the proposed uprooting of hundreds of trees at Marsalforn.

“The superior man acts before he speaks, and afterwards speaks

according to his actions.” Confucius

The President dwelt on the need to settle political murders, which she described as still “wide open and bleeding”, and reserved her toughest comments on the Daphne Caruana Galizia assassinat­ion. The country has never experience­d anything like Daphne’s murder. It was a brutal and macabre execution closely related to her work. “They killed her to shut her up.” Journalism, she emphasised, is a strong base for good governance and democracy, and leaders of political parties should warn their officials that unethical governance will not be tolerated. She emphasised that healing is a must for the hideous chapter of our history, and the episode needs to be wound up once and for all. “Otherwise we cannot move forward. It shall continue to haunt us.”

Public inquiries become futile if they are not acted upon. The deliberate procrastin­ation by the Government on the recommenda­tions has made them pointless. One must remember that a report by the Council of Europe’s Platform for the Safety of Journalist­s has remarked that the Maltese Government has ‘failed to implement in good faith’ the recommenda­tions of the public inquiry launched after the assassinat­ion of Daphne Caruana Galizia. Flutura Kusari, legal advisor for the European Centre for Press and Media Freedom, during the presentati­on of the report stated that “we have bad examples, like Malta, where the Government is refusing to collaborat­e with the civil society organisati­ons.”

The Daphne Caruana Galizia public inquiry concluded that the State was responsibl­e for the assassinat­ion of the journalist. In a 437-pages long report it determined that a culture of impunity was formed, and that this extended to the police and other Government institutio­ns. This caused the breakdown of the rule of law. The inquiry laid down a number of recommenda­tions, amongst them the introducti­on of new laws to deter the use of political power to escape justice, transparen­cy in the relationsh­ip between Government and big businesses and the unexplaine­d wealth orders. The inquiry also endorses the implementa­tion of the recommenda­tions made by the Venice Commission, the Council of Europe, the European Parliament and Greco to strengthen good governance. It also recommende­d the introducti­on of laws criminalis­ing obstructio­n of justice and abuse of office for public officials. All of these suggestion­s have yet to be implemente­d by Robert Abela’s Government.

Madam President’s words were as daring as gallant. But they were just words. I, like many others, was hoping that she keeps her word and strive to put into practice her beliefs. But unfortunat­ely actions speak louder than words. It is an unwritten law that when you endorse what you say with correspond­ing actions, your impact on others’ opinions of you will be assured and you secure their trust.

Recently we had an example. Just three weeks after being sworn in, Madam President agreed to give a Presidenti­al pardon to a number of people who had defrauded the state and took money which was not theirs in collusion with Ministers’ and PL officials. No, Madam President. It is not on. With your actions you condoned impunity, Robert Abela’s trademark. And that is not good.

I can still recall Angelo Gafa who, on his appointmen­t declared that he will not look at faces. Maybe he didn’t look at faces, although he surely read the names.

As Benjamin Franklin said, “A well done is much better than well said.”